The brief
The top-rated elementary schools in Indianapolis for 2026 are In Math & Science Academy (9.7/10), George W Julian School 57 (9.4/10), and Fishback Creek Public Academy (9.3/10), based on MySchoolScout's analysis of 178 elementary schools with real test data included in this ranking. Schools with estimated (proxy) scores are excluded from this ranking.
Indianapolis has 138 ranked elementary schools, giving families a wide field to evaluate — but performance varies significantly across the metro. Indy Steam Academy leads all schools with a 9.8 out of 10, followed closely by George W Julian School 57 at 9.5 and IN Math & Science Academy and Center for Inquiry School 70, both at 9.3. The average composite score across all ranked schools sits at 6.1 out of 10, which means the gap between a typical school and a top performer is substantial. Only 36 schools — about 26% of the total — score 7 or higher, so strong options exist but require some searching. The table below lets you sort by overall score, test performance, and other key measures to find schools that match what matters most to your family. Start with the top of the rankings or filter by neighborhood to narrow your search.
Ranked by composite score; the tick is the score on the 1–10 axis.
- 19.7
- 29.4
- 39.3
- 49.2
- 58.9
- 68.9
- 78.9
- 88.8
- 98.7
- 108.6
All 178 ranked
Every ranked school on the axis, then the ledger.Top 25 of 178
Rating · students · student-teacher ratio · grades- 1In Math & Science AcademycharterIn Math & Science Academystudents 535student-teacher ratio 10.9:1grades Kindergarten–8th
- 2George W Julian School 57Indianapolis Public Schoolsstudents 208student-teacher ratio 10.9:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 3Fishback Creek Public AcademyMsd Pike Townshipstudents 480student-teacher ratio 16.0:1grades Pre-K–5th
- 4St Joan of Arc/diocesestudents 155student-teacher ratio 7.0:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 5William Mckinley School 39Indianapolis Public Schoolsstudents 404student-teacher ratio 12.6:1grades Pre-K–6th
- 6Spring Mill Elementary SchoolMsd Washington Townshipstudents 478student-teacher ratio 13.3:1grades Kindergarten–5th
- 7Mcclelland Elementary SchoolMsd Wayne Townshipstudents 725student-teacher ratio 11.2:1grades Pre-K–6th
- 8St Richard's Episcopal Schoolstudents 258student-teacher ratio 8.9:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 9Center for Inquiry School 70Indianapolis Public Schoolsstudents 454student-teacher ratio 16.2:1grades Kindergarten–8th
- 10Pleasant Run Elementary SchoolMsd Warren Townshipstudents 523student-teacher ratio 14.9:1grades Kindergarten–4th
- 11Maria Montessori International Acastudents 64student-teacher ratio 8.0:1grades Pre-K–5th
- 12St Monica Catholic Schoolstudents 322student-teacher ratio 10.1:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 13Sycamore Schoolstudents 366student-teacher ratio 6.5:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 14Pla at George H Fisher School 93charterPla At George H Fisher School 93students 413student-teacher ratio 11.8:1grades Kindergarten–6th
- 15South Creek ElementaryFranklin Township Com Sch Corpstudents 628student-teacher ratio 18.5:1grades Kindergarten–3rd
- 16Ips/butler Lab at Eliza Blaker 55Indianapolis Public Schoolsstudents 445student-teacher ratio 16.5:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 17Center for Inquiry School 2Indianapolis Public Schoolsstudents 435student-teacher ratio 14.0:1grades Kindergarten–8th
- 18Clearwater Elementary SchoolMsd Washington Townshipstudents 720student-teacher ratio 19.5:1grades Kindergarten–5th
- 19Little Flower Catholic Schoolstudents 353student-teacher ratio 11.8:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 20St Lawrence Catholic Schoolstudents 196student-teacher ratio 11.5:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 21St Roch Catholic Schoolstudents 256student-teacher ratio 9.7:1grades Kindergarten–8th
- 22The Oaks Academystudents 971student-teacher ratio 7.9:1grades Pre-K–8th
- 23Lowell Elementary SchoolMsd Warren Townshipstudents 482student-teacher ratio 15.1:1grades Kindergarten–4th
- 24Cold Spring SchoolIndianapolis Public Schoolsstudents 369student-teacher ratio 12.7:1grades Kindergarten–8th
- 25St Luke Catholic Schoolstudents 57student-teacher ratio 1.2:1grades Kindergarten–Kindergarten
Scores are based on 2024-25 data from the NCES Common Core of Data and Indiana education department. Rankings are relative to all public elementary schools in Indiana. Learn about our methodology.
The map
The top 25 pinned; open a pin for the campus.Campus by campus
What each of the top ten reports.- 1
In Math & Science Academy
In Math & Science Academy
535 students · 10.9:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Kindergarten–8th
Top 1% in Indiana · charter
- Academics
- 9.4
- Growth
- 9.9
- Environment
- 9.4
- 2
George W Julian School 57
Indianapolis Public Schools
208 students · 10.9:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Pre-K–8th
Top 1% in Indiana
- Academics
- 8.1
- Growth
- 10.0
- Environment
- 9.9
- 3
Fishback Creek Public Academy
Msd Pike Township
480 students · 16.0:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Pre-K–5th
Top 1% in Indiana
- Academics
- 8.9
- Growth
- 9.9
- Environment
- 8.4
- 4
St Joan of Arc/diocese
155 students · 7.0:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Pre-K–8th
Top 1% in Indiana
- Academics
- not scored
- Growth
- not scored
- Environment
- not scored
- 5
William Mckinley School 39
Indianapolis Public Schools
404 students · 12.6:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Pre-K–6th
Top 4% in Indiana
- Academics
- 8.2
- Growth
- 9.0
- Environment
- 9.9
- 6
Spring Mill Elementary School
Msd Washington Township
478 students · 13.3:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Kindergarten–5th
Top 4% in Indiana
- Academics
- 7.1
- Growth
- 9.8
- Environment
- 9.6
- 7
Mcclelland Elementary School
Msd Wayne Township
725 students · 11.2:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Pre-K–6th
Top 4% in Indiana
- Academics
- 7.5
- Growth
- 9.6
- Environment
- 9.1
- 8
St Richard's Episcopal School
258 students · 8.9:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Pre-K–8th
Top 3% in Indiana
- Academics
- not scored
- Growth
- not scored
- Environment
- not scored
- 9
Center for Inquiry School 70
Indianapolis Public Schools
454 students · 16.2:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Kindergarten–8th
Top 6% in Indiana
- Academics
- 7.0
- Growth
- 9.3
- Environment
- 9.9
- 10
Pleasant Run Elementary School
Msd Warren Township
523 students · 14.9:1 student-teacher ratio · grades Kindergarten–4th
Top 7% in Indiana
- Academics
- 7.0
- Growth
- 9.7
- Environment
- 8.4
Questions
What is the best elementary school in Indianapolis, Indiana?
According to MySchoolScout's 2026 rankings, In Math & Science Academy is the top-rated elementary school in Indianapolis with a composite score of 9.7/10. The score blends student growth, poverty-adjusted academic performance, and school environment — plus college readiness for high schools — with equity shown as context, not scored.
How many elementary schools are in Indianapolis, Indiana?
Indianapolis has 185 elementary schools, including 33 charter schools. Of these, 179 have enough data for a full composite rating on MySchoolScout.
What is the average elementary school rating in Indianapolis?
Among 179 Indianapolis elementary schools with a composite score, the average is 6.7/10. Scores range from 1.0 (bottom of the state) to 10.0 (top 1% in Indiana).
How does MySchoolScout rate elementary schools?
Schools with enough data receive a 1-10 composite score that blends Student Growth, Poverty-Adjusted Academic Achievement, and School Environment — plus College Readiness for high schools. Weights vary by school level, with growth counting most in elementary and middle grades. Equity data is shown for context but not scored. All scores are computed within Indiana, so schools are compared to peers in the same state. Data comes from the NCES Common Core of Data and state education departments.
What is a good school rating on MySchoolScout?
In Indiana, 37% of scored public schools rate 7 or above, and the median is 6.5. Anything above 8 is exceptional. Our ratings are relative to other schools in Indiana, not a national comparison, because each state has different testing standards.
Are charter schools included in the Indianapolis elementary school rankings?
Indianapolis has 33 charter elementary schools in its directory. Charter schools that meet this ranking's data requirements are included alongside traditional public schools using the same composite scoring methodology.
How should I use this ranking?
Consider your child's learning style. Some children thrive in smaller settings (look for student-teacher ratios under 14:1), while others do well in larger, more social environments. The schools on this list range widely in size and approach.
Look beyond the composite score. A school ranked #15 might be the best fit if it excels in growth (improving student outcomes year over year) even if its raw academic score is lower. Click into individual school profiles to see the breakdown.
Visit your top choices. Walk the hallways during a school day. Watch how teachers interact with students. Ask about before- and after-school care, transportation, and parent involvement. These details matter more than any dataset.
Explore more
- Best middle schools in Indianapolis2026 rankings and ratings
- Best high schools in Indianapolis2026 rankings and ratings
- All 304 schools in IndianapolisElementary, middle and high
- Indiana schoolsStatewide rankings and city comparisons
- Our methodologyHow we calculate school ratings