Skip to main content

Carrollton High School vs Mackinaw High School

Carrollton High School has a higher overall rating of 6.9/10 compared to 5.6/10. Carrollton High School is significantly larger with 449 students, about 3.2× the size of Mackinaw High School (141). In math proficiency, Carrollton High School leads at 17.0%.

Attendance data is under correction. A public school's existing Resources & Environment score and overall rating shown here may still reflect an unverified attendance input.

Carrollton High School

Saginaw, MI

6.9/10
High School9th – 12th

449 students

Mackinaw High School

Saginaw, MI

5.6/10
High School9th – 12th

141 students

Keep or send this comparison

One email with the link. We add you to School Scout updates; unsubscribe anytime.

Send to my realtor

Open an email to my realtor

Ratings Comparison

MetricCarrollton High SchoolMackinaw High School
Overall Rating6.9 / 105.6 / 10
Academic Score7.66.0
Growth Score9.09.4
Diversity Index——
Free/Reduced Lunch87.8%83.7%
Environment Score3.81.9
State Rank#1,084 of 3,198#2,188 of 3,198
State Percentile66th32th

Test Scores

SubjectCarrollton High SchoolMackinaw High School
Math Proficiency17.0%10.0%
Math (State Avg)——
ELA Proficiency47.0%30.0%
ELA (State Avg)——

School Details

DetailCarrollton High SchoolMackinaw High School
TypeHigh SchoolHigh School
Grades9th – 12th9th – 12th
Enrollment449141
Student-Teacher Ratio20.4:123.5:1
Free/Reduced Lunch87.8%83.7%
Graduation Rate (4yr, Class of 2023)85–89%11–19%
DistrictCarrollton Public SchoolsSaginaw Township Community Schools
CitySaginawSaginaw

Neighborhood

MetricSaginaw (48604)Saginaw (48603)
Median Household Income$53,804$65,690
Median Home Value$93,200$181,800
Median Rent$928$1,019
College Educated (Bachelor's+)24.2%37.0%
Poverty Rate28.8%13.8%
Avg Commute16 min21 min
View Carrollton High School Full Profile →View Mackinaw High School Full Profile →