McKinley Elementary School vs William J. McGinn Elementary School

William J. McGinn Elementary School has a higher overall rating of 7.0/10 compared to 6.2/10. William J. McGinn Elementary School is significantly larger with 549 students, about 1.8× the size of McKinley Elementary School (309). In math proficiency, William J. McGinn Elementary School leads at 77.0%.

Attendance data is under correction. A public school's existing Resources & Environment score and overall rating shown here may still reflect an unverified attendance input.

McKinley Elementary School

Westfield, NJ

6.2/10

Elementary School1st – 5th

309 students

William J. McGinn Elementary School

Scotch Plains, NJ

7.0/10

Elementary SchoolKindergarten – 4th

549 students

Keep or send this comparison

Ratings Comparison

Metric	McKinley Elementary School	William J. McGinn Elementary School
Overall Rating	6.2 / 10	7.0 / 10
Academic Score	8.4	8.8
Growth Score	4.3	7.4
Diversity Index	—	—
Free/Reduced Lunch	1.6%	0.7%
Environment Score	7.9	3.5
State Rank	#1,466 of 2,466	#954 of 2,466
State Percentile	41th	61th

Test Scores

Subject	McKinley Elementary School	William J. McGinn Elementary School
Math Proficiency	77.0%	77.0%
Math (State Avg)	—	—
ELA Proficiency	62.0%	73.0%
ELA (State Avg)	—	—

School Details

Detail	McKinley Elementary School	William J. McGinn Elementary School
Type	Elementary School	Elementary School
Grades	1st – 5th	Kindergarten – 4th
Enrollment	309	549
Student-Teacher Ratio	10.7:1	14.1:1
Free/Reduced Lunch	1.6%	0.7%
District	Westfield Public School District	Scotch Plains-Fanwood School District
City	Westfield	Scotch Plains

Neighborhood

Metric	Westfield (07090)	Scotch Plains (07076)
Median Household Income	$212,700	$173,564
Median Home Value	$930,500	$696,900
Median Rent	$2,211	$1,816
College Educated (Bachelor's+)	76.7%	65.0%
Poverty Rate	2.1%	2.8%
Avg Commute	36 min	35 min

View McKinley Elementary School Full Profile →View William J. McGinn Elementary School Full Profile →