FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL vs ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY
ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY has a higher overall rating of 9.4/10 compared to 8.9/10. In math proficiency, FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL leads at 92.0%.
FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Orange Park, FL
659 students
ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY
Orange Park, FL
693 students
Ratings Comparison
| Metric | FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | 8.9 / 10 | 9.4 / 10 |
| Academic Score | 9.7 | 9.9 |
| Growth Score | 8.2 | 9.3 |
| Diversity Index | — | — |
| Free/Reduced Lunch | 23.7% | 31.6% |
| Environment Score | 9.6 | 8.8 |
| State Rank | #223 of 3,778 | #51 of 3,778 |
| State Percentile | 94th | 99th |
Test Scores
| Subject | FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY |
|---|---|---|
| Math Proficiency | 92.0% | 82.0% |
| Math (State Avg) | — | — |
| ELA Proficiency | 92.0% | 87.0% |
| ELA (State Avg) | — | — |
School Details
| Detail | FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Elementary School | Elementary School |
| Grades | Pre-K – 6th | Pre-K – 6th |
| Enrollment | 659 | 693 |
| Student-Teacher Ratio | 12.7:1 | 12.2:1 |
| Free/Reduced Lunch | 23.7% | 31.6% |
| Chronic Absenteeism (SY 2022-23) | 12.7% | 30.6% |
| District | CLAY | CLAY |
| City | Orange Park | Orange Park |
Neighborhood
| Metric | Orange Park (32003) | Orange Park (32003) |
|---|---|---|
| Median Household Income | $119,046 | $119,046 |
| Median Home Value | $387,400 | $387,400 |
| Median Rent | $1,918 | $1,918 |
| College Educated (Bachelor's+) | 47.9% | 47.9% |
| Poverty Rate | 5.1% | 5.1% |
| Avg Commute | 30 min | 30 min |
The data story: FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL vs ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY
Robert M. Paterson Elementary and Fleming Island Elementary School sit 1.8 miles apart in Orange Park, Florida, yet their overall ratings diverge by a meaningful half-point: Paterson earns a 9.4/10 against Fleming Island's 8.9/10. The state rank gap is even sharper — Paterson sits at #7 of 3,777 Florida elementary schools while Fleming Island lands at #70 of 3,777, a difference of 63 positions in one of the nation's largest state systems. Both are strong performers by any measure, but Paterson occupies a genuinely elite tier.
The academic and growth scores tell a split story. Fleming Island Elementary holds a 9.6/10 academic score, 0.4 points above Paterson's 9.2/10, meaning its students are currently hitting higher proficiency benchmarks. Paterson counters with a 9.7/10 growth score versus Fleming Island's 8.5/10 — a 1.2-point gap that reflects how much ground students gain year over year once enrolled. Parents weighing current achievement against student trajectory will find these two metrics pulling in opposite directions. Paterson's growth advantage is the more unusual of the two: a 9.7 growth score in a field of 3,777 schools is harder to come by than a 9.6 academic rating.
Enrollment and classroom dynamics are similar but not identical. Paterson carries 693 students to Fleming Island's 659, a modest 34-student difference. Paterson's student-teacher ratio of 12.2:1 is slightly tighter than Fleming Island's 12.7:1, giving Paterson a marginal classroom-size edge. On socioeconomic composition, 32% of Paterson students qualify for free or reduced lunch compared to 24% at Fleming Island — an 8-point gap suggesting Fleming Island draws from a somewhat more affluent attendance zone.
Both schools serve grades PK through 06, so families with children from pre-K through sixth grade face no structural difference in grade span. The decision therefore rests entirely on the performance and demographic distinctions above rather than any programmatic or grade-level gap between the two campuses.
Editorial summary generated April 2026 · sonnet
Who each school fits
FLEMING ISLAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Robert M. Paterson Elementary suits families who prioritize how much their child will grow academically each year. Its 9.7/10 growth score — 1.2 points above Fleming Island's — makes it the stronger pick for parents whose child needs to accelerate or close gaps, and its #7 statewide rank signals a track record that is difficult to match within 1.8 miles.
ROBERT M. PATERSON ELEMENTARY
Fleming Island Elementary School fits families focused on current academic achievement levels, with a 9.6/10 academic score edging Paterson's 9.2. Its slightly lower student-teacher ratio of 12.7:1 versus the district norm and a more affluent peer group — 24% free/reduced lunch — may appeal to parents whose child is already performing at or above grade level and will benefit from a high-proficiency peer environment.