Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 vs James A Allison Elementary Sch 3
Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 and James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 are very closely rated, both scoring around 9.2 out of 10. James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 is significantly larger with 242 students, about 1.7× the size of Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 (146). In math proficiency, James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 leads at 87.0%.
Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1
Speedway, IN
146 students
James A Allison Elementary Sch 3
Speedway, IN
242 students
Ratings Comparison
| Metric | Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 | James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | 9.2 / 10 | 9.1 / 10 |
| Academic Score | 9.7 | 9.6 |
| Growth Score | 9.2 | 8.6 |
| Diversity Index | — | — |
| Free/Reduced Lunch | 38.4% | 64.5% |
| Environment Score | 8.6 | 9.8 |
| State Rank | #48 of 1,823 | #57 of 1,823 |
| State Percentile | 97th | 97th |
Test Scores
| Subject | Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 | James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Math Proficiency | 87.0% | 87.0% |
| Math (State Avg) | — | — |
| ELA Proficiency | 92.0% | 87.0% |
| ELA (State Avg) | — | — |
School Details
| Detail | Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 | James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Elementary School | Elementary School |
| Grades | Pre-K – 6th | Kindergarten – 6th |
| Enrollment | 146 | 242 |
| Student-Teacher Ratio | 16.2:1 | 13.4:1 |
| Free/Reduced Lunch | 38.4% | 64.5% |
| Chronic Absenteeism (SY 2022-23) | 7.5% | 3.7% |
| District | School Town of Speedway | School Town of Speedway |
| City | Speedway | Speedway |
Neighborhood
| Metric | Speedway (46224) | Speedway (46224) |
|---|---|---|
| Median Household Income | $53,731 | $53,731 |
| Median Home Value | $166,500 | $166,500 |
| Median Rent | $1,048 | $1,048 |
| College Educated (Bachelor's+) | 24.3% | 24.3% |
| Poverty Rate | 17.6% | 17.6% |
| Avg Commute | 24 min | 24 min |
The data story: Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 vs James A Allison Elementary Sch 3
James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 holds a meaningful edge in Indiana's statewide rankings, sitting at #8 of 1,823 schools compared to Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1's rank of #42 — a 34-position gap between two schools separated by just 0.8 miles in Speedway. Both schools score in the top tier overall, but Allison's 9.5/10 overall rating outpaces Fisher's 9.0/10, a difference driven less by raw academics than by growth trajectory and the population each school serves.
The academic scores are nearly identical — Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 posts a 9.7/10 against James A Allison Elementary Sch 3's 9.6/10, a negligible 0.1-point difference. Where Allison pulls ahead is in growth: its 9.7/10 growth score beats Fisher's 9.5/10, indicating that Allison students are making slightly faster academic progress year over year relative to their starting points. Both scores are exceptional in absolute terms, but Allison's growth edge is what lifts its overall rank into Indiana's top 10.
The two schools differ sharply in enrollment and classroom density. Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 enrolls 146 students against James A Allison Elementary Sch 3's 242, and Fisher's student-teacher ratio of 16.2:1 is notably higher than Allison's 13.4:1 — nearly three fewer students per teacher. Allison also serves a significantly higher-need population, with 64% of students qualifying for free or reduced lunch compared to 38% at Fisher. Allison's top-10 state ranking while educating a majority economically disadvantaged population makes its growth score particularly notable.
One structural difference separates the schools at the lower grades: Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 begins at pre-kindergarten, while James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 starts at kindergarten. Both schools run through sixth grade. Families seeking a PK option within Speedway will find Fisher as the only choice of the two, while those enrolling a kindergartner or older student can access either campus.
Editorial summary generated April 2026 · sonnet
Who each school fits
Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1
Carl G Fisher Elementary School 1 suits families with pre-kindergarten-aged children, since it is the only one of the two offering PK. It also fits parents who prioritize a smaller, less crowded campus — 146 students versus 242 — and are comfortable with a slightly higher student-teacher ratio in exchange for a tighter-knit school community. Its #42 statewide ranking still places it well inside Indiana's top 3% of elementary schools.
James A Allison Elementary Sch 3
James A Allison Elementary Sch 3 is the stronger fit for families prioritizing demonstrated student growth and the lowest possible student-teacher ratio — 13.4:1 gives teachers more individual contact time. Its #8 statewide rank, achieved while serving a 64% economically disadvantaged population, signals an exceptionally high-performing instructional environment. Parents of kindergarten-through-sixth-grade students who want Indiana's elite academic trajectory should weigh Allison first.