Orchard View School vs Middlebury Elementary School

Middlebury Elementary School ranks #11 out of 1,823 Indiana elementary schools, placing it in the top 1% statewide. Orchard View School earns a strong #88 out of 1,823 — top 5% — but that 77-position gap translates to a concrete 0.7-point overall rating difference: 9.5/10 for Orchard View School versus 9.5/10 for Middlebury Elementary School at 9.5/10. Both are high performers by any measure, but Middlebury Elementary School holds a clear statewide edge for parents who track rankings closely.

Academically, Middlebury Elementary School scores a perfect 10.0/10 against Orchard View School's already-strong 9.6/10 — a 0.4-point gap that mirrors the schools' overall separation. The growth score tells the same story: Middlebury Elementary School again posts a 10.0/10 while Orchard View School earns a 9.5/10. That half-point growth delta is meaningful because growth scores measure how much students improve year over year, independent of starting point. Middlebury Elementary School is not only achieving at a higher level — it is accelerating students faster.

Orchard View School enrolls 341 students compared to Middlebury Elementary School's 198, making Orchard View roughly 72% larger despite both serving the same KG–03 grade band. Middlebury Elementary School's smaller headcount pairs with a slightly tighter student-teacher ratio of 14.1:1 versus Orchard View School's 14.8:1, meaning each teacher at Middlebury Elementary School manages roughly one fewer student on average. Free and reduced-price lunch eligibility runs slightly higher at Middlebury Elementary School (34%) than at Orchard View School (29%), a five-point gap suggesting Middlebury Elementary School serves a somewhat higher proportion of economically diverse families while still posting superior academic outcomes.

Both schools sit just 1.0 mile apart in Middlebury, Indiana and cover identical grade spans — kindergarten through third grade — so the choice is a pure quality comparison, not a logistics or grade-structure trade-off. The data consistently favors Middlebury Elementary School across every measured dimension: overall rating, academic proficiency, and student growth. Orchard View School's larger campus and slightly higher enrollment may offer broader peer-group exposure, but neither school distinguishes itself through documented specialty programs in the available data.