Orchard View School vs Middlebury Elementary School
Orchard View School and Middlebury Elementary School are very closely rated, both scoring around 8.8 out of 10. Orchard View School is significantly larger with 341 students, about 1.7× the size of Middlebury Elementary School (198). In math proficiency, Middlebury Elementary School leads at 87.0%.
Orchard View School
Middlebury, IN
341 students
Middlebury Elementary School
Middlebury, IN
198 students
Ratings Comparison
| Metric | Orchard View School | Middlebury Elementary School |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | 8.8 / 10 | 9.2 / 10 |
| Academic Score | 9.6 | 9.9 |
| Growth Score | 9.1 | 9.5 |
| Diversity Index | — | — |
| Free/Reduced Lunch | 28.7% | 34.3% |
| Environment Score | 6.6 | 7.5 |
| State Rank | #109 of 1,823 | #45 of 1,823 |
| State Percentile | 94th | 98th |
Test Scores
| Subject | Orchard View School | Middlebury Elementary School |
|---|---|---|
| Math Proficiency | 82.0% | 87.0% |
| Math (State Avg) | — | — |
| ELA Proficiency | 87.0% | 92.0% |
| ELA (State Avg) | — | — |
School Details
| Detail | Orchard View School | Middlebury Elementary School |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Elementary School | Elementary School |
| Grades | Kindergarten – 3rd | Kindergarten – 3rd |
| Enrollment | 341 | 198 |
| Student-Teacher Ratio | 14.8:1 | 14.1:1 |
| Free/Reduced Lunch | 28.7% | 34.3% |
| Chronic Absenteeism (SY 2022-23) | 9.7% | 8.1% |
| District | Middlebury Community Schools | Middlebury Community Schools |
| City | Middlebury | Middlebury |
Neighborhood
| Metric | Middlebury (46540) | Middlebury (46540) |
|---|---|---|
| Median Household Income | $99,664 | $99,664 |
| Median Home Value | $297,800 | $297,800 |
| Median Rent | $1,074 | $1,074 |
| College Educated (Bachelor's+) | 18.9% | 18.9% |
| Poverty Rate | 6.2% | 6.2% |
| Avg Commute | 18 min | 18 min |
The data story: Orchard View School vs Middlebury Elementary School
Middlebury Elementary School ranks #11 out of 1,823 Indiana elementary schools, placing it in the top 1% statewide. Orchard View School earns a strong #88 out of 1,823 — top 5% — but that 77-position gap translates to a concrete 0.7-point overall rating difference: 9.5/10 for Orchard View School versus 9.5/10 for Middlebury Elementary School at 9.5/10. Both are high performers by any measure, but Middlebury Elementary School holds a clear statewide edge for parents who track rankings closely.
Academically, Middlebury Elementary School scores a perfect 10.0/10 against Orchard View School's already-strong 9.6/10 — a 0.4-point gap that mirrors the schools' overall separation. The growth score tells the same story: Middlebury Elementary School again posts a 10.0/10 while Orchard View School earns a 9.5/10. That half-point growth delta is meaningful because growth scores measure how much students improve year over year, independent of starting point. Middlebury Elementary School is not only achieving at a higher level — it is accelerating students faster.
Orchard View School enrolls 341 students compared to Middlebury Elementary School's 198, making Orchard View roughly 72% larger despite both serving the same KG–03 grade band. Middlebury Elementary School's smaller headcount pairs with a slightly tighter student-teacher ratio of 14.1:1 versus Orchard View School's 14.8:1, meaning each teacher at Middlebury Elementary School manages roughly one fewer student on average. Free and reduced-price lunch eligibility runs slightly higher at Middlebury Elementary School (34%) than at Orchard View School (29%), a five-point gap suggesting Middlebury Elementary School serves a somewhat higher proportion of economically diverse families while still posting superior academic outcomes.
Both schools sit just 1.0 mile apart in Middlebury, Indiana and cover identical grade spans — kindergarten through third grade — so the choice is a pure quality comparison, not a logistics or grade-structure trade-off. The data consistently favors Middlebury Elementary School across every measured dimension: overall rating, academic proficiency, and student growth. Orchard View School's larger campus and slightly higher enrollment may offer broader peer-group exposure, but neither school distinguishes itself through documented specialty programs in the available data.
Editorial summary generated May 2026 · sonnet
Who each school fits
Orchard View School
Orchard View School fits families who want a high-performing elementary school with a larger student body — useful if your child benefits from a wider peer group or if Orchard View's attendance zone is the closer option. At #88 in Indiana, it remains an objectively strong choice even if it trails Middlebury Elementary School on every headline metric.
Middlebury Elementary School
Middlebury Elementary School fits families who prioritize maximum academic outcome and growth acceleration in a smaller setting. Its #11 Indiana rank, perfect 10.0/10 academic and growth scores, and tighter 14.1:1 student-teacher ratio make it the stronger option for parents who want every available edge in their child's early elementary years.