Brookhaven Elementary vs Maryvale Elementary

Maryvale Elementary ranks #19 of 1,363 Maryland elementary schools with an overall rating of 9.4/10, while Brookhaven Elementary sits at #80 of 1,363 with an 8.9/10 — a meaningful separation in a competitive state field. Both schools land in the top 6% statewide, but Maryvale's position near the very top of the rankings represents a distinct tier of performance that parents weighing long-term academic outcomes should factor into their decision.

On academics, the gap widens: Maryvale Elementary scores 9.5/10 versus Brookhaven Elementary's 8.2/10 — a 1.3-point difference that signals a consistent edge in measured proficiency. Growth scores are closer but still favor Maryvale, 9.5/10 versus Brookhaven's 9.0/10, meaning Maryvale students are not only arriving at higher proficiency levels but advancing at a faster rate as well. For a family prioritizing raw academic output and year-over-year student progress, these are the most consequential numbers on the page.

Brookhaven Elementary serves 426 students against Maryvale Elementary's 631, and that size difference shows up directly in classroom ratios: Brookhaven's student-teacher ratio of 11.2:1 is materially tighter than Maryvale's 14.0:1. Brookhaven also serves a higher share of economically disadvantaged students — 58% on free or reduced lunch compared to Maryvale's 47% — which reflects different community compositions two and a half miles apart in the same city.

Both schools serve grades PK through 5, so families with children spanning those grades face no structural difference in grade coverage. The distinction is environmental: Brookhaven's smaller enrollment and lower ratio mean more individualized adult attention per child, while Maryvale's scale supports the resources and staffing mix that typically underpin its stronger academic scores.