PS 15 ROBERTO CLEMENTE vs AMISTAD DUAL LANGUAGE SCHOOL

PS 15 Roberto Clemente and Amistad Dual Language School rank among the very best schools in New York State, with both placing in the top 20 of 4,739 schools. Amistad edges ahead in overall rating — 9.3 out of 10 versus PS 15's 9.2 — and holds the stronger state rank at #14 compared to PS 15's #20. The gap between them is narrow at just 0.1 points overall, but the schools diverge meaningfully beneath that headline number in ways that matter depending on what a family is looking for.

On raw academic proficiency, PS 15 Roberto Clemente outperforms Amistad: a 9.1 academic score versus Amistad's 8.7, a 0.4-point edge that reflects stronger tested outcomes at the current point in time. The growth story runs in the opposite direction. Amistad Dual Language School posts a 9.9 growth score against PS 15's already-impressive 9.5, meaning students at Amistad are accelerating faster relative to their starting points — the highest growth rating possible, and 0.4 points ahead of PS 15. Families weighing where a child currently tests versus where a school is sending students academically will read those two numbers differently.

PS 15 Roberto Clemente serves 190 students across prekindergarten through grade 5, with a student-teacher ratio of 7.9:1 — one of the most intimate classroom environments available at this performance level anywhere in the state. Amistad enrolls 393 students, more than double, with a student-teacher ratio of 9.6:1. Both schools serve similarly high-need populations: PS 15's free and reduced-price lunch rate is 86%, Amistad's is 84%, making their exceptional ratings all the more notable as measures of what each school delivers for its community.

Amistad Dual Language School's grade span extends through grade 8, offering continuity from kindergarten through middle school within a single building — a structural advantage that eliminates a school transition entirely. PS 15 tops out at grade 5 and begins at prekindergarten, making it the only option of the two for families with children under kindergarten age. Amistad's bilingual program design is embedded in its name and mission, while PS 15's smaller size and lower ratio favor families prioritizing close teacher-student relationships over programmatic breadth.