Madeira High School vs Mariemont High School

Mariemont High School holds a 9.7/10 overall rating versus Madeira High School's 9.2/10 — a 0.5-point gap that translates to a dramatic difference in statewide standing. Mariemont High School ranks #1 of 3,440 schools in Ohio, while Madeira High School ranks #24 of 3,440. Both are genuinely elite by any measure, but Mariemont sits alone at the top of the state while Madeira sits firmly among Ohio's top 1 percent.

The academic scores are close — Madeira High School earns a 9.8/10 versus Mariemont High School's perfect 10.0/10 — but the growth score tells a sharper story. Mariemont High School scores 9.9/10 on growth compared to Madeira High School's 8.5/10, a 1.4-point delta. Growth measures how much students improve beyond what their starting point predicts, so Mariemont is not only achieving at a higher level but accelerating students more aggressively relative to their incoming trajectories.

The two schools are nearly identical in size — Madeira High School enrolls 442 students and Mariemont High School enrolls 452 — so neither offers a meaningfully larger or smaller community. Where they differ slightly is in student-teacher ratio: Mariemont High School's 12.9:1 edges out Madeira High School's 13.8:1, meaning Mariemont students have modestly more face time with teachers on average. Both schools serve grades 09–12 and sit just 3.9 miles apart in the Cincinnati metro.

Both schools operate within the same grade band and comparable enrollment bands, so the distinctions come down to execution rather than structure. Mariemont High School's growth advantage suggests a faculty or program that consistently draws more out of students regardless of baseline, while Madeira High School's near-perfect academic score shows it is producing outstanding absolute outcomes. Families choosing between two schools this close in profile will find that Mariemont's top state rank and growth edge are the clearest differentiators.