Compass Community School Berclair Campus vs Compass Community School Hickory Hill Campus

Compass Community School Hickory Hill Campus holds a clear edge in overall standing, rated 9.2/10 against Compass Community School Berclair Campus's 8.8/10 — a 0.4-point gap that translates into a dramatic difference in state rank. Hickory Hill sits at #33 of 1,785 Tennessee schools while Berclair ranks #94 of 1,785, placing Hickory Hill in roughly the top 2% of the state compared to Berclair's top 5%. Both are strong performers by any objective measure, but families specifically seeking a top-tier statewide ranking will find Hickory Hill the sharper choice.

The academic score delta drives most of that gap. Compass Community School Hickory Hill Campus scores 7.4/10 on academics versus Compass Community School Berclair Campus's 6.5/10 — a 0.9-point difference that reflects meaningfully higher tested proficiency. Growth scores, however, are essentially identical: Berclair posts a 9.9/10 and Hickory Hill a 10.0/10, meaning both campuses are exceptional at accelerating student progress regardless of where kids start. A student joining either school below grade level can expect aggressive catch-up trajectory; the separation lies in absolute proficiency outcomes, not momentum.

The two campuses are 7.2 miles apart and serve the same grade band — KG through 8 — but differ in size and staffing density. Berclair enrolls 229 students against Hickory Hill's 254, and Berclair's student-teacher ratio of 10.9:1 is notably tighter than Hickory Hill's 12.7:1. Families who prioritize smaller class sizes and more direct teacher access per student will find Berclair's numbers favorable, even though Hickory Hill outperforms on rankings.

Both schools share the Compass Community School network and an identical grade span, so curriculum framework and school culture should be consistent across campuses. The practical decision comes down to geography, class-size preference, and whether absolute academic standing or daily instructional attention matters more to a given family. Neither campus serves a specialized program that the other lacks, so the comparison stays grounded in performance metrics and logistics rather than program differentiation.