Milk (Harvey) Civil Rights Elementary vs Grattan Elementary

Milk (Harvey) Civil Rights Elementary and Grattan Elementary sit 0.8 miles apart in San Francisco and serve the same grade band, KG–05, yet their profiles diverge in ways that matter for families making a concrete choice. Milk Civil Rights Elementary edges ahead overall at 9.3/10 versus Grattan Elementary's 9.2/10 — a slim gap — but the state rank context gives that margin weight: Milk Civil Rights Elementary ranks #90 of 9,533 California schools while Grattan Elementary ranks #135 of 9,533, a 45-position difference at a level where every slot represents stiff competition.

The academic versus growth split is the sharpest contrast between the two schools. Grattan Elementary posts a higher academic score, 8.7/10 compared to Milk Civil Rights Elementary's 8.1/10, meaning students at Grattan are reaching higher raw proficiency benchmarks. Milk Civil Rights Elementary, however, scores a perfect 10.0/10 on growth versus Grattan Elementary's 9.5/10, indicating that students at Milk Civil Rights Elementary are advancing at an exceptional rate relative to their starting points. Families weighing current achievement levels against year-over-year learning velocity will find a genuine trade-off here, not a clear winner.

Enrollment and demographics separate the two schools further. Milk Civil Rights Elementary enrolls 154 students against Grattan Elementary's 384 — more than twice the headcount — making Grattan a substantially larger campus by San Francisco elementary standards. Milk Civil Rights Elementary's smaller population pairs with a slightly better student-teacher ratio, 19.2:1 versus Grattan Elementary's 20.2:1. Free and reduced-price lunch eligibility stands at 31% at Milk Civil Rights Elementary compared to 15% at Grattan Elementary, reflecting a more economically diverse student body at Milk.

Both schools cover the identical grade range, KG–05, so neither offers an extended pathway or earlier entry advantage. The distinction lies in scale and character: Milk Civil Rights Elementary functions as a tight-knit, high-growth campus with greater economic diversity, while Grattan Elementary operates at more than double the enrollment with a stronger absolute academic proficiency score.