Crieve Hall Elementary vs Sylvan Park Elementary

Sylvan Park Elementary ranks #3 of 1,785 Tennessee schools while Crieve Hall Elementary ranks #50 of 1,785 — both exceptional placements, but a 47-position gap that reflects a meaningful overall rating difference. Sylvan Park Elementary scores 9.7 out of 10 overall against Crieve Hall Elementary's 9.0, a 0.7-point gap that places Sylvan Park among the very top elementary schools statewide. For Nashville parents, both schools sit well clear of the state median, but Sylvan Park's position just outside the top 1% of all Tennessee elementary schools is difficult to match.

The two schools share an identical academic score — Crieve Hall Elementary and Sylvan Park Elementary both earn 9.8 out of 10 — meaning neither school has a measurable advantage in raw proficiency. The gap opens on growth. Sylvan Park Elementary posts a growth score of 9.8 out of 10, a full 1.4 points above Crieve Hall Elementary's 8.4. That delta signals that students at Sylvan Park are advancing at a faster year-over-year rate relative to comparable peers, even though both schools start from similar academic baselines. For families prioritizing how quickly their child progresses rather than just where they test, that difference carries real weight.

Crieve Hall Elementary enrolls 499 students against Sylvan Park Elementary's 439, a difference of 60 students across identical KG–05 grade spans. Student-teacher ratios are nearly the same: 14.3-to-1 at Crieve Hall Elementary versus 14.6-to-1 at Sylvan Park Elementary. Neither school shows a meaningful classroom-size advantage. Both operate as mid-size neighborhood elementaries without the crowding that can affect attention and resources at larger campuses.

Both schools serve kindergarten through fifth grade only, so families needing a K–5 program will find equivalent grade coverage at either location. The two schools sit 7.3 miles apart within Nashville, making them realistically cross-town options rather than true neighborhood alternates for most families. The decision comes down primarily to Sylvan Park Elementary's standout growth trajectory versus Crieve Hall Elementary's strong overall standing and comparable academic foundation.