Crieve Hall Elementary vs Waverly-Belmont Elementary School

Waverly-Belmont Elementary School ranks #30 of 1,785 schools in Tennessee, placing it 20 spots ahead of Crieve Hall Elementary at #30 vs. #50 statewide — a meaningful gap within Nashville's top tier. The overall rating difference is narrow at 0.2 points (9.2 vs. 9.0), but that gap masks meaningful differences under the hood. Both schools clear the 90th percentile statewide, so parents choosing between them are comparing two genuinely high-performing options, not a strong school versus a weak one.

On academics, Crieve Hall Elementary holds a 0.3-point edge: 9.8/10 versus Waverly-Belmont Elementary School's 9.5/10, making it one of the strongest raw proficiency performers in the state. Waverly-Belmont Elementary School flips the script on growth — its 9.5/10 growth score outpaces Crieve Hall Elementary's 8.4/10 by 1.1 full points. Growth scores measure how much students advance relative to academic peers, so Waverly-Belmont Elementary School is adding more learning per year on top of already-high baseline achievement. For families who want a school that accelerates kids rather than simply serving students who arrive ahead, that 1.1-point growth delta is the most important number on the page.

Enrollment at both schools is comparable — 499 students at Crieve Hall Elementary and 528 at Waverly-Belmont Elementary School — but classroom staffing differs. Crieve Hall Elementary's student-teacher ratio of 14.3:1 is meaningfully tighter than Waverly-Belmont Elementary School's 16.5:1, translating to roughly two fewer students per teacher. That difference can matter for families prioritizing individualized attention, particularly for kids who benefit from more adult access during the school day. Both schools serve kindergarten through fifth grade, so grade structure is not a differentiating factor.

The two schools sit 4.5 miles apart in Nashville, which for most families makes geography a realistic decision input. Crieve Hall Elementary's lower ratio and elite academic score favor one profile; Waverly-Belmont Elementary School's superior state rank and growth trajectory favor another. Neither school is the obvious default — the right choice depends on what a family weights most.