Excellent
#62 of 478 private schools in IN
Top 13% of private schools
St Matthew Catholic School
Elementary School
4100 E 56TH ST, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Enrollment
318
Student-Teacher
12:1
Score
8.1
Grades
Pre-K – 8th
Enrollment
318
Student-Teacher
12:1
Score
8.1
Grades
Pre-K – 8th
Data vintage
2021-22
Data vintage2021-22
How this school compares
Indiana private schools
#62 of 478
In Indianapolis
#16 of 64
public schools
Shortlisting around St Matthew Catholic School?
Use this profile as one decision point, then compare nearby options, source confidence, and commute fit before picking a neighborhood around it.
Shortlist starter
Start with these real page-level signals, then use the full table and map below.
St Matthew Catholic School
Elementary School in Indianapolis · grades Pre-K – 8th. Start here, then compare fit against nearby and district options.
Eastwood Middle School
0.8 mi away. Use as a geographic alternative in the same move search.
Cathedral High School
0.9 mi away. Use as a geographic alternative in the same move search.
About St Matthew Catholic School
St Matthew Catholic School is a private elementary school in Indianapolis, IN. St Matthew Catholic School serves approximately 318 students, and covers grades Pre-K-8th, and has a 12:1 student-teacher ratio. St Matthew Catholic School has a current MySchoolScout rating of 8.1 out of 10 and ranks #62 of 478 private schools in IN.
Structured state assessment records for St Matthew Catholic School show 32% math proficiency (2025 ILEARN) and 55% reading/ELA proficiency (2025 ILEARN).
- This school 8.1 · Excellent
- IN avg 6.6
What Parents Should Know
St Matthew Catholic School is private, so it runs independently of the local district and sets its own curriculum. That freedom cuts both ways depending on what you want for your child. If you're considering it, start with the practical questions: tuition, financial aid, and how admissions work.
Compare to Public Schools
BetaHow St Matthew Catholic School compares to 191 public schools serving similar grades in Indianapolis, IN
Student Demographics
Nearby Elementary Schools
| School | Rating |
|---|---|
| St Matthew Catholic School (this school) | 8.1 |
| Eastwood Middle School | 7.4 |
| Merle Sidener Gifted Academy | 9.4 |
| Robert Lee Frost School 106 | 3.8 |
| ACE Preparatory Academy | 7.3 |
| Rousseau McClellan School 91 | 5.4 |
| Indy Steam Academy | 8.6 |
| The Genius School | 6.4 |
| GEO Next Generation Academy | 3.8 |
| Arlington Community Middle School | 6.0 |
| Avondale Meadows Middle School | 7.5 |
| Avondale Meadows Academy | 3.6 |
| Tindley Genesis Academy | 2.0 |
| Charles A Tindley Accelerated Sch | 4.9 |
| IPS/Butler Lab at Eliza Blaker 55 | 7.9 |
| Indiana School For The Deaf | 4.8 |
| Brook Park Elementary School | 2.8 |
| IN Math & Science Academy - North | 4.0 |
| Clearwater Elementary School | 8.8 |
| Hoosier College and Career Academy | 4.5 |
| Center for Inquiry School 84 | 9.3 |
Showing 20 of 191 schools. View all schools in Indianapolis
Demographics sourced from NCES Private School Survey (PSS) and Common Core of Data (CCD). Comparisons are based on enrollment-weighted averages.
Score Breakdown
PreliminaryWhat This Rating Measures
This rating reflects classroom size, instructional time, student diversity, community resources, and school characteristics. Private schools are ranked against other private schools in IN.
Data Unavailable
View data sources
Score basis: Private school model
Data coverage: 80% of scoring components had data
Components scored: 4 of 5
Ranking pool: Private schools in IN
Test Scores IN ILEARN (2024-25)
Based on 17 test records from IN state assessments. About our data
Student Demographics NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)
Source: NCES Private School Survey (PSS)
Location
4100 E 56TH ST, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Nearby Alternatives
Families considering St Matthew Catholic School may also want to explore other elementary schools in the area. Clearwater Elementary School (rated 8.8/10, 2.8 miles away), which scores slightly higher. Another option is Indy Steam Academy (rated 8.6/10, 1.8 miles away), which scores slightly higher. Additionally, IPS/Butler Lab at Eliza Blaker 55 (rated 7.9/10, 2.1 miles away), with a very similar rating. For more schools in Indianapolis, see our Indianapolis schools guide .
Nearby Schools
20 within 2.3 mi| School | Distance | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Eastwood Middle School Indianapolis | 0.8 mi | 7.4 |
| CATHEDRAL HIGH SCHOOL Indianapolis | 0.9 mi | 6.7 |
| Merle Sidener Gifted Academy Indianapolis | 1.4 mi | 9.4 |
| Indy Steam Academy Indianapolis | 1.8 mi | 8.6 |
| Robert Lee Frost School 106 Indianapolis | 1.4 mi | 3.8 |
| GEO Next Generation Academy Indianapolis | 1.8 mi | 3.8 |
| The Genius School Indianapolis | 1.8 mi | 6.4 |
| ACE Preparatory Academy Indianapolis | 1.6 mi | 7.3 |
| Avondale Meadows Academy Indianapolis | 2.0 mi | 3.6 |
| Avondale Meadows Middle School Indianapolis | 2.0 mi | 7.5 |
| Rousseau McClellan School 91 Indianapolis | 1.7 mi | 5.4 |
| Charles A Tindley Accelerated Sch Indianapolis | 2.1 mi | 4.9 |
| Tindley Genesis Academy Indianapolis | 2.0 mi | 2.0 |
| HARRIOT TUBMAN SCHOOL OF EXCELLENCE Indianapolis | 2.0 mi | — |
| Arlington Community Middle School Indianapolis | 2.0 mi | 6.0 |
| Thrival Academy Indianapolis | 2.0 mi | 2.5 |
| IPS/Butler Lab at Eliza Blaker 55 Indianapolis | 2.1 mi | 7.9 |
| IN Math & Science Academy - North Indianapolis | 2.6 mi | 4.0 |
| Clearwater Elementary School Indianapolis | 2.8 mi | 8.8 |
| NORTHSIDE MONTESSORI Indianapolis | 2.3 mi | — |
Neighborhood Census ACS (2019-2023)
Census data for ZIP 46220 (ACS 2019-2023 5-Year Estimates) · Data sources
Median Income
$103,735
Median Home Value
$329,700
Median Rent
$1,330/mo
Population
36,159
College Educated
66.9%
Homeownership
64.9%
Avg Commute
24.2 min
Poverty Rate
7.6%
Median Age
34.9
Similar Schools
Schools in the same state with comparable level, size, and ratings
| School | Rating |
|---|---|
| Carlisle Elementary School Carlisle, IN | 8.1 |
| Chamberlain Elementary School Goshen, IN | 8.1 |
| KINGSWAY CHRISTIAN SCHOOL Avon, IN | 8.1 |
| Knapp Elementary School Michigan City, IN | 8.1 |
| Liberty Elementary School Liberty, IN | 8.1 |
| Morgan Township Elementary School Valparaiso, IN | 8.1 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about St Matthew Catholic School
What grades does St Matthew Catholic School serve?
St Matthew Catholic School serves students in grades Pre-K through 8th.
How many students attend St Matthew Catholic School?
St Matthew Catholic School has an enrollment of approximately 318 students.
What is the student-teacher ratio at St Matthew Catholic School?
The student-teacher ratio at St Matthew Catholic School is 12:1. A lower ratio generally means more individual attention per student. The national average is approximately 11:1 for private schools.
How does St Matthew Catholic School rank in IN?
St Matthew Catholic School ranks #62 of 478 private schools in IN.
What is St Matthew Catholic School's MySchoolScout rating?
St Matthew Catholic School has a current MySchoolScout rating of 8.1 out of 10. This score combines the level-appropriate components shown in the rating breakdown; equity data is shown separately for context.
What are the test scores at St Matthew Catholic School?
Based on loaded state assessment records, St Matthew Catholic School has 32% math proficiency (2025 ILEARN) and 55% reading/ELA proficiency (2025 ILEARN).
Is St Matthew Catholic School a private school?
Yes, St Matthew Catholic School is a private coeducational school with a Roman Catholic affiliation. Private schools are not required to participate in state standardized testing, so academic performance data may be limited compared to public schools.
Is St Matthew Catholic School a religious school?
St Matthew Catholic School has a Roman Catholic religious affiliation.
Neighborhood Context
Powered by 
Quick Facts NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)
- Grades
- Pre-K – 8th
- Enrollment
- 318
- Gender Split
- 60% M / 40% F
- Student-Teacher Ratio
- 12:1
- Teachers (FTE)
- 27
- Type
- private
- Coed Status
- coed
- Affiliation
- Roman Catholic
- School Day
- 7.2 hours
- Days Per Year
- 180 days
- Setting
- Large City
- County
- Marion County
- Phone
- (317) 251-3997
Resources & Links
How we rate schools
A clear 1–10 score built from public data — growth, academics, and learning environment. No hidden criteria, no pay-to-play.
See how we rateRelated reading
Get school insights in your inbox
New rankings, best-schools lists, and parent guides — delivered free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.