Below Average
#964 of 992 private schools in NY
Fayette Mennonite School
Middle School
1468 LEADER RD, Waterloo, NY 13165
Enrollment
47
Student-Teacher
12.1:1
Score
4.1
Grades
1st – 8th
Enrollment
47
Student-Teacher
12.1:1
Score
4.1
Grades
1st – 8th
Data vintage
2021-22
Data vintage2021-22
How this school compares
New York private schools
#964 of 992
Shortlisting around Fayette Mennonite School?
Use this profile as one decision point, then compare nearby options, source confidence, and commute fit before picking a neighborhood around it.
Shortlist starter
Start with these real page-level signals, then use the full table and map below.
Fayette Mennonite School
Middle School in Waterloo · grades 1st – 8th. Start here, then compare fit against nearby and district options.
Skoi-yase School
5.2 mi away. Use as a geographic alternative in the same move search.
Romulus Central School
5.3 mi away. Use as a geographic alternative in the same move search.
About Fayette Mennonite School
Fayette Mennonite School is a private middle school in Waterloo, NY. Fayette Mennonite School serves approximately 47 students, and covers grades 1st-8th, and has a 12.1:1 student-teacher ratio. Fayette Mennonite School has a current MySchoolScout rating of 4.1 out of 10 and ranks #964 of 992 private schools in NY.
- This school 4.1 · Below Average
- NY avg 6.1
What Parents Should Know
At 47 students, Fayette Mennonite School is on the smaller side. That usually buys more individual attention and teachers who know every kid by name, with the trade-off of fewer electives and extracurriculars than a larger school can staff. Ask what activities it actually offers.
Fayette Mennonite School is private, so it runs independently of the local district and sets its own curriculum. That freedom cuts both ways depending on what you want for your child. If you're considering it, start with the practical questions: tuition, financial aid, and how admissions work.
Fayette Mennonite School sits in a rural area, which can mean longer drives for some families. Rural schools are often community anchors with smaller classes, but check transportation, after-school options, and access to specialized services before you commit.
Compare to Public Schools
BetaHow Fayette Mennonite School compares to the 4 public schools in Waterloo, NY
Student Demographics
All Schools in Waterloo
| School | Rating |
|---|---|
| Fayette Mennonite School (this school) | 4.1 |
| SKOI-YASE SCHOOL | 6.6 |
| LA FAYETTE SCHOOL | 4.7 |
| WATERLOO MIDDLE SCHOOL | 3.6 |
| WATERLOO HIGH SCHOOL | 7.3 |
Demographics sourced from NCES Private School Survey (PSS) and Common Core of Data (CCD). Comparisons are based on enrollment-weighted averages.
Score Breakdown
PreliminaryWhat This Rating Measures
This rating reflects classroom size, instructional time, student diversity, community resources, and school characteristics. Private schools are ranked against other private schools in NY.
Data Unavailable
View data sources
Score basis: Private school model
Data coverage: 80% of scoring components had data
Components scored: 4 of 5
Ranking pool: Private schools in NY
Test Scores
Test score data not yet available for this school.
Student Demographics NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)
Source: NCES Private School Survey (PSS)
Location
1468 LEADER RD, Waterloo, NY 13165
Nearby Alternatives
Families considering Fayette Mennonite School may also want to explore other middle schools in the area. UNION SPRINGS MIDDLE SCHOOL (rated 7.8/10, 9.2 miles away, in nearby Union Springs), which scores notably higher. Another option is GENEVA MIDDLE SCHOOL (rated 4.4/10, 7.5 miles away, in nearby Geneva), which scores slightly higher. Additionally, SENECA FALLS MIDDLE SCHOOL (rated 3.8/10, 7.8 miles away, in nearby Seneca Falls), with a very similar rating. For more schools in Waterloo, see our Waterloo schools guide .
Nearby Schools
20 within 9.2 mi| School | Distance | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| SKOI-YASE SCHOOL Waterloo | 5.2 mi | 6.6 |
| ROMULUS CENTRAL SCHOOL Romulus | 5.3 mi | 6.0 |
| LA FAYETTE SCHOOL Waterloo | 6.1 mi | 4.7 |
| WATERLOO MIDDLE SCHOOL Waterloo | 6.3 mi | 3.6 |
| WATERLOO HIGH SCHOOL Waterloo | 6.4 mi | 7.3 |
| ELIZABETH CADY STANTON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Seneca Falls | 7.0 mi | 4.8 |
| FRANK M KNIGHT ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Seneca Falls | 7.5 mi | 6.2 |
| SENECA FALLS MIDDLE SCHOOL Seneca Falls | 7.8 mi | 3.8 |
| MYNDERSE ACADEMY Seneca Falls | 7.8 mi | 7.6 |
| CHILDRENS HOURS SCHOOL Geneva | 6.8 mi | 5.2 |
| ST FRANCIS DE SALES-ST STEPHEN Geneva | 6.9 mi | 6.0 |
| WEST STREET ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Geneva | 7.2 mi | 7.1 |
| GENEVA HIGH SCHOOL Geneva | 7.4 mi | 8.2 |
| GENEVA MIDDLE SCHOOL Geneva | 7.5 mi | 4.4 |
| NORTH STREET ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Geneva | 7.6 mi | 3.4 |
| FINGER LAKES CHRISTIAN SCHOOL Seneca Falls | 8.7 mi | 5.2 |
| SOUTH SENECA MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL Ovid | 10.5 mi | 4.3 |
| GROVE CREEK SCHOOL Ovid | 11.0 mi | — |
| UNION SPRINGS HIGH SCHOOL Union Springs | 9.2 mi | 8.2 |
| UNION SPRINGS MIDDLE SCHOOL Union Springs | 9.2 mi | 7.8 |
Neighborhood Census ACS (2019-2023)
Census data for ZIP 13165 (ACS 2019-2023 5-Year Estimates) · Data sources
Median Income
$63,915
Median Home Value
$118,600
Median Rent
$926/mo
Population
9,429
College Educated
20.6%
Homeownership
68%
Avg Commute
22 min
Poverty Rate
10.8%
Median Age
45.9
Similar Schools
Schools in the same state with comparable level, size, and ratings
| School | Rating |
|---|---|
| CLYDE MENNONITE PAROCHIAL SCHOOL Clyde, NY | 4.5 |
| VALLEY VIEW SCHOOL Penn Yan, NY | 3.3 |
| CONQUEST MENNONITE SCHOOL Port Byron, NY | 5.0 |
| FLAT IRON SCHOOL Conewango Valley, NY | 2.9 |
| NORA CRONIN PRESENTATION ACADEMY Newburgh, NY | 5.3 |
| HIDDEN VALLEY SCHOOL Clymer, NY | — |
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Fayette Mennonite School
What grades does Fayette Mennonite School serve?
Fayette Mennonite School serves students in grades 1st through 8th.
How many students attend Fayette Mennonite School?
Fayette Mennonite School has an enrollment of approximately 47 students.
What is the student-teacher ratio at Fayette Mennonite School?
The student-teacher ratio at Fayette Mennonite School is 12.1:1. A lower ratio generally means more individual attention per student. The national average is approximately 11:1 for private schools.
How does Fayette Mennonite School rank in NY?
Fayette Mennonite School ranks #964 of 992 private schools in NY.
What is Fayette Mennonite School's MySchoolScout rating?
Fayette Mennonite School has a current MySchoolScout rating of 4.1 out of 10. This score combines the level-appropriate components shown in the rating breakdown; equity data is shown separately for context.
Is Fayette Mennonite School a private school?
Yes, Fayette Mennonite School is a private coeducational school with a Mennonite affiliation. Private schools are not required to participate in state standardized testing, so academic performance data may be limited compared to public schools.
Is Fayette Mennonite School a religious school?
Fayette Mennonite School has a Mennonite religious affiliation.
Explore More Schools
Neighborhood Context
Powered by 
Quick Facts NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)
- Grades
- 1st – 8th
- Enrollment
- 47
- Gender Split
- 57% M / 43% F
- Student-Teacher Ratio
- 12.1:1
- Teachers (FTE)
- 4
- Type
- private
- Coed Status
- coed
- Affiliation
- Mennonite
- School Day
- 6.5 hours
- Days Per Year
- 180 days
- Setting
- Distant Rural
- County
- Seneca County
- Phone
- (315) 730-4813
Resources & Links
How we rate schools
A clear 1–10 score built from public data — growth, academics, and learning environment. No hidden criteria, no pay-to-play.
See how we rateRelated reading
- Best Public Schools in New York 2026: Top Districts from NYC to the Suburbsbest schools
- Best Schools in New York, NY — 2026 Rankingsbest schools
- Best States for Public Schools in 2026: A Complete Rankingdata insights
- Charter Schools vs Public Schools: What the Data Actually Shows (2026)school choice
- Student-Teacher Ratio by State: Complete 2026 Rankingsdata insights
Get school insights in your inbox
New rankings, best-schools lists, and parent guides — delivered free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.