Average
#519 of 991 private schools in NY
Nativity of Our Lord School
Elementary School
4414 S BUFFALO ST, Orchard Park, NY 14127
Estimated academic score. This school does not have standardized test data. Based on NY statewide data. Learn more
Enrollment
158
Student-Teacher
9.9:1
Score
6.2
Grades
Kindergarten – 8th
Enrollment
158
Student-Teacher
9.9:1
Score
6.2
Grades
Kindergarten – 8th
Updated
2021-22
Updated 2021-22
How this school compares
In Orchard Park
#2 of 2
public schools
New York elementary schools
#228 of 486
About Nativity of Our Lord School
Nativity of Our Lord School is a public elementary school located in Orchard Park, Erie County, New York. Serving kindergarten through eighth grade students, the school has an enrollment of 158 and maintains a student-teacher ratio of 9.9:1 with 16 full-time equivalent teachers. Despite its MySchoolScout rating of 4.2 out of 10 and a state ranking of #57 among 991 schools in New York, the school focuses on fostering a supportive learning environment where students receive individual attention from dedicated educators.
Located in a large suburban area, Nativity of Our Lord School benefits from a close-knit community that values education. The setting offers both quiet residential neighborhoods and easy access to local amenities and resources. While academic test scores are not currently available, the school is committed to nurturing student development and providing comprehensive support for its diverse group of learners.
What Parents Should Know
With an enrollment of 158 students, Nativity of Our Lord School is a smaller school where families often find a close-knit community atmosphere. Smaller settings can mean more individual attention from teachers and staff, though they may offer fewer extracurricular options than larger schools.
With a student-teacher ratio of 9.9:1, Nativity of Our Lord School offers a notably low ratio compared to the national average. This typically means smaller class sizes and more opportunities for one-on-one interaction between students and teachers.
As a private school, Nativity of Our Lord School operates independently from the local public school district. Families considering this school should inquire about tuition costs, financial aid availability, and the admissions process. Private schools are not required to follow the same curriculum standards as public schools, which can be either an advantage or a consideration depending on your priorities.
Compare to Public Schools
BetaHow Nativity of Our Lord School compares to 5 public schools serving similar grades in Orchard Park, NY
Student Demographics
Nearby Elementary Schools
| School | Rating |
|---|---|
| Nativity of Our Lord School (this school) | 6.2 |
| ORCHARD PARK MIDDLE SCHOOL | 4.0 |
| SOUTH DAVIS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | 7.4 |
| ELLICOTT ROAD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | 7.7 |
| EGGERT ROAD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | 7.0 |
| WINDOM ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | 7.4 |
Demographics sourced from NCES Private School Survey (PSS) and Common Core of Data (CCD). Comparisons are based on enrollment-weighted averages.
Score Breakdown
What This Rating Measures
This rating reflects classroom size, instructional time, student diversity, community resources, and school characteristics. Private schools are ranked against other private schools in NY.
Data Unavailable
View data sources
Score basis: Private school model
Data coverage: 80% of scoring components had data
Components scored: 4 of 5
Ranking pool: Private schools in NY
Test Scores
Test score data not yet available for this school.
Student Demographics NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)
Source: NCES Private School Survey (PSS)
Location
4414 S BUFFALO ST, Orchard Park, NY 14127
Nearby Alternatives
Families considering Nativity of Our Lord School may also want to explore other elementary schools in the area. ELLICOTT ROAD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL (rated 7.7/10, 1.4 miles away), which scores notably higher. Another option is SOUTH DAVIS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL (rated 7.4/10, 0.3 miles away), which scores notably higher. Additionally, WINDOM ELEMENTARY SCHOOL (rated 7.4/10, 2.8 miles away), which scores notably higher. For more schools in Orchard Park, see our Orchard Park schools guide .
Nearby Schools
20 within 4.5 miNeighborhood Census ACS (2019-2023)
Census data for ZIP 14127 (ACS 2019-2023 5-Year Estimates) · Data sources
Median Income
$106,071
Median Home Value
$328,700
Median Rent
$1,196/mo
Population
30,783
College Educated
52.6%
Homeownership
73.4%
Avg Commute
20.9 min
Poverty Rate
7%
Median Age
44.7
Community Profile
The community surrounding Nativity of Our Lord School has a median household income of $106,071. It is a well-educated community where 53% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher. The median home value in the area is $328,700, with a median rent of $1,196/month. The local poverty rate of 7.0% is relatively low. The average commute for residents is 21 minutes. Source: U.S. Census ACS 2022 5-Year Estimates.
Similar Schools
Schools in the same state with comparable level, size, and ratings
| School | Rating |
|---|---|
| CHRIST THE KING ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Amherst, NY | 6.2 |
| CHRIST THE KING SCHOOL Bronx, NY | 6.2 |
| LINCOLN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Newark, NY | 6.2 |
| PARISHVILLE-HOPKINTON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Parishville, NY | 6.2 |
| PETERBORO STREET ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Canastota, NY | 6.2 |
| PROMISE CHRISTIAN ACADEMY Flushing, NY | 6.2 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Nativity of Our Lord School
What grades does Nativity of Our Lord School serve?
Nativity of Our Lord School serves students in grades Kindergarten through 8th.
How many students attend Nativity of Our Lord School?
Nativity of Our Lord School has an enrollment of approximately 158 students.
What is the student-teacher ratio at Nativity of Our Lord School?
The student-teacher ratio at Nativity of Our Lord School is 9.9:1. A lower ratio generally means more individual attention per student. The national average is approximately 11:1 for private schools.
How does Nativity of Our Lord School rank in NY?
Nativity of Our Lord School is ranked #519 out of 991 private schools in NY.
What is Nativity of Our Lord School's MySchoolScout rating?
Nativity of Our Lord School has a composite rating of 6.2 out of 10 on MySchoolScout. This score combines academic performance, student growth, and school environment into a single score. Equity data is shown separately for context.
Is Nativity of Our Lord School a private school?
Yes, Nativity of Our Lord School is a private coeducational school with a Roman Catholic affiliation. Private schools are not required to participate in state standardized testing, so academic performance data may be limited compared to public schools.
Is Nativity of Our Lord School a religious school?
Nativity of Our Lord School has a Roman Catholic religious affiliation.
Explore More Schools
Quick Facts NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)
- Grades
- Kindergarten – 8th
- Enrollment
- 158
- Gender Split
- 50% M / 50% F
- Student-Teacher Ratio
- 9.9:1
- Teachers (FTE)
- 16
- Type
- private
- Coed Status
- coed
- Affiliation
- Roman Catholic
- School Day
- 6.5 hours
- Days Per Year
- 170 days
- Setting
- Large Suburb
- County
- ERIE
- Phone
- (716) 662-7572
- Data Year
- 2022–2023
Resources & Links
How We Rate Schools
Every school receives a composite score from 1 to 10 based on four pillars: Academic Performance (50%), Student Growth (20%), Equity (15%), and Learning Environment (15%). Scores are built from publicly available data including standardized test results, enrollment figures, and school climate indicators.
Read our full methodologyRelated reading
- Best Public Schools in New York 2026: Top Districts from NYC to the Suburbsbest schools
- Best Schools in New York, NY — 2026 Rankingsbest schools
- Best States for Public Schools in 2026: A Complete Rankingdata insights
- Charter Schools vs Public Schools: What the Data Actually Shows (2026)school choice
- Student-Teacher Ratio by State: Complete 2026 Rankingsdata insights
Get school insights in your inbox
New rankings, best-schools lists, and parent guides — delivered free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.