Skip to main content

Very Good

#129 of 713 private schools in OH

Top 18% of private schools

St Mary School

Elementary School

26 W ST, Shelby, OH 44875

Private Estimated Score

Estimated academic score. This school does not have standardized test data. Based on OH statewide data. Learn more

Enrollment

53

Student-Teacher

6.5:1

Score

7.8

Grades

Pre-K – 6th

Updated 2021-22

How this school compares

In Shelby

#1 of 2

public schools

Ohio elementary schools

#68 of 409

About St Mary School

ST MARY SCHOOL serves 53 students from prekindergarten through sixth grade in Shelby, Ohio. This elementary school stands out with an exceptionally low student-teacher ratio of 6.5:1, supported by 8 full-time equivalent teachers, creating an intimate learning environment where students receive individualized attention. The school has earned strong recognition, ranking #92 out of 713 elementary schools statewide and placing in the 87th percentile with a MySchoolScout rating of 8.0 out of 10.

This impressive ranking reflects the school's commitment to educational excellence despite its small size. ST MARY SCHOOL draws families from a stable working-class community where the median household income is $62,327 and median home values are $138,700. The neighborhood maintains a 12.2% poverty rate, while 16% of residents hold bachelor's degrees or higher.

This demographic mix creates a diverse student body that benefits from the school's personalized approach to education. The small enrollment allows teachers to know each student well and tailor instruction to individual needs. Parents choosing ST MARY SCHOOL often value the close-knit community atmosphere and the opportunity for their children to receive focused attention throughout their elementary years.

The school is situated in a town on the fringe of an urban area, providing families with both small-town charm and access to broader metropolitan resources.

What Parents Should Know

With an enrollment of 53 students, St Mary School is a smaller school where families often find a close-knit community atmosphere. Smaller settings can mean more individual attention from teachers and staff, though they may offer fewer extracurricular options than larger schools.

With a student-teacher ratio of 6.5:1, St Mary School offers a notably low ratio compared to the national average. This typically means smaller class sizes and more opportunities for one-on-one interaction between students and teachers.

As a private school, St Mary School operates independently from the local public school district. Families considering this school should inquire about tuition costs, financial aid availability, and the admissions process. Private schools are not required to follow the same curriculum standards as public schools, which can be either an advantage or a consideration depending on your priorities.

Compare to Public Schools

Beta

How St Mary School compares to the 4 public schools in Shelby, OH

Student-Teacher Ratio
6.5:1
This School
vs
17.8:1
Public Avg
Avg School Size
53
This School
vs
746
Public Avg
Avg School Scout Rating
7.8
This School
vs
6.7
Public Avg

Student Demographics

White 83% vs 0%
Hispanic 9.4% vs 0%
St Mary School Shelby Public Avg

All Schools in Shelby

School Rating
St Mary School (this school) 7.8
Shelby Elementary School 7.0
Shelby Middle School 6.1
Shelby High School 5.7
Pioneer Career & Technology 7.9

Demographics sourced from NCES Private School Survey (PSS) and Common Core of Data (CCD). Comparisons are based on enrollment-weighted averages.

Score Breakdown

What This Rating Measures

This rating reflects classroom size, instructional time, student diversity, community resources, and school characteristics. Private schools are ranked against other private schools in OH.

Classroom Attention
? Student-teacher ratio calibrated against other private schools. Lower ratios mean more individual attention. (30% of overall score)
A+ 9.5 / 10
View breakdown
Student-Teacher Ratio 6.5:1
Instructional Commitment
? Total annual instructional hours based on school day length and days per year. (15% of overall score)
A 8.9 / 10
View breakdown
School Day Length 7 hours
Annual Instructional Hours 1,260
Diversity & Inclusion
? Racial and ethnic diversity of the student body using Simpson's diversity index. (20% of overall score)
B+ 7.2 / 10
View breakdown
Diversity Index 30%
Community Context

Data Unavailable

School Profile
? Enrollment size and grade span breadth — indicators of program depth and peer community. (15% of overall score)
C+ 4.3 / 10
View breakdown
Enrollment 53
View data sources

Score basis: Private school model

Data coverage: 80% of scoring components had data

Components scored: 4 of 5

Ranking pool: Private schools in OH

Test Scores

Test score data not yet available for this school.

Student Demographics NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)

White 83.0%
Hispanic 9.4%
Two or More 7.5%

Source: NCES Private School Survey (PSS)

Location

26 W ST, Shelby, OH 44875

Nearby Alternatives

Families considering St Mary School may also want to explore other elementary schools in the area. Shiloh Elementary School (rated 7.2/10, 7.3 miles away, in nearby Plymouth), with a comparable rating. Another option is Stingel Elementary School (rated 7.2/10, 8.3 miles away, in nearby Ontario), with a comparable rating. Additionally, Shelby Elementary School (rated 7.0/10, 0.4 miles away), with a comparable rating. For more schools in Shelby, see our Shelby schools guide .

Nearby Schools

20 within 10.6 mi
School Distance Rating
Shelby Elementary School Shelby 0.4 mi 7.0
Shelby Middle School Shelby 0.4 mi 6.1
Shelby High School Shelby 0.6 mi 5.7
Pioneer Career & Technology Shelby 1.4 mi 7.9
SACRED HEART SCHOOL Shelby 4.3 mi 5.7
Plymouth High School Plymouth 7.2 mi 7.5
Shiloh Middle School Plymouth 7.2 mi 6.6
Shiloh Elementary School Plymouth 7.3 mi 7.2
Crestline High School Crestline 7.0 mi 6.1
Crestline Elementary School Crestline 7.0 mi 3.8
Crestline Preschool Crestline 7.0 mi 5.6
ST JOSEPH CATHOLIC SCHOOL Crestline 7.5 mi 5.2
Ontario High School Mansfield 8.2 mi 5.2
Ontario Middle School Mansfield 8.3 mi 7.2
Stingel Elementary School Ontario 8.3 mi 7.2
Sherman Elementary School Mansfield 8.5 mi 4.7
Springmill STEM Elementary Mansfield 8.5 mi 6.3
Foundation Academy Mansfield 9.3 mi 3.0
The Richland School of Academic Arts Mansfield 9.9 mi 6.7
CELERYVILLE CHRISTIAN SCHOOL Willard 10.6 mi 7.5

Neighborhood Census ACS (2019-2023)

Census data for ZIP 44875 (ACS 2019-2023 5-Year Estimates) · Data sources

Median Income

$60,669

Median Home Value

$146,500

Median Rent

$727/mo

Population

14,026

College Educated

14.7%

Homeownership

75.1%

Avg Commute

20.7 min

Poverty Rate

12%

Median Age

42

Community Profile

The community surrounding St Mary School has a median household income of $60,669. It is a community where 15% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher. The median home value in the area is $146,500, with a median rent of $727/month. The area has a poverty rate of 12.0%. The average commute for residents is 21 minutes. Source: U.S. Census ACS 2022 5-Year Estimates.

Similar Schools

Schools in the same state with comparable level, size, and ratings

School Rating
NICHOLAS SCHOOL Piqua, OH 7.8
ST JOHN LUTHERAN SCHOOL Defiance, OH 7.7
Westlake Academy Westlake, OH 7.7
THE GODDARD SCHOOL LOCATED IN South Lebanon, OH 7.9
Vanlue Elementary School Vanlue, OH 7.9
ST AUGUSTINE CATHOLIC SCHOOL Napoleon, OH 7.6

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about St Mary School

What grades does St Mary School serve?

St Mary School serves students in grades Pre-K through 6th.

How many students attend St Mary School?

St Mary School has an enrollment of approximately 53 students.

What is the student-teacher ratio at St Mary School?

The student-teacher ratio at St Mary School is 6.5:1. A lower ratio generally means more individual attention per student. The national average is approximately 11:1 for private schools.

How does St Mary School rank in OH?

St Mary School is ranked #129 out of 713 private schools in OH.

What is St Mary School's MySchoolScout rating?

St Mary School has a composite rating of 7.8 out of 10 on MySchoolScout. This score combines academic performance, student growth, and school environment into a single score. Equity data is shown separately for context.

Is St Mary School a private school?

Yes, St Mary School is a private coeducational school with a Roman Catholic affiliation. Private schools are not required to participate in state standardized testing, so academic performance data may be limited compared to public schools.

Is St Mary School a religious school?

St Mary School has a Roman Catholic religious affiliation.

11 schools nearby View map →

Neighborhood Context

Walk Score
56 Somewhat Walkable
Bike Score
49 Somewhat Bikeable
City Safety
Elevated (1,415/100K)

Powered by Walk Score

FBI UCR 2024. City-level (Shelby). Data >1 year old.

Quick Facts NCES PSS (SY 2021-22)

Grades
Pre-K – 6th
Enrollment
53
Gender Split
57% M / 43% F
Student-Teacher Ratio
6.5:1
Teachers (FTE)
8
Type
private
Coed Status
coed
Affiliation
Roman Catholic
School Day
7 hours
Days Per Year
180 days
Setting
Fringe Town
County
RICHLAND
Data Year
2022–2023

How We Rate Schools

Every school receives a composite score from 1 to 10 based on four pillars: Academic Performance (50%), Student Growth (20%), Equity (15%), and Learning Environment (15%). Scores are built from publicly available data including standardized test results, enrollment figures, and school climate indicators.

Read our full methodology

Related reading

Get school insights in your inbox

New rankings, best-schools lists, and parent guides — delivered free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.