Best Schools in Sugarcreek, Ohio
16 schools · 7 Elementary · 7 Middle · 1 High · 1 Other
Choosing a school in Sugarcreek?
Use this page to compare every school in Sugarcreek by level, neighborhood, and district — and find the right fit, not just the top of the list.

Shortlist starter
Start with these real page-level signals, then use the full table and map below.
Miller Avenue Elementary School
Elementary · Garaway Local. Ranked from real test data; compare it on the map and table below.
Garaway High School
High · Garaway Local. Ranked from real test data; compare it on the map and table below.
Legacy Christian School
Other. Ranked from real test data; compare it on the map and table below.
The short answer
The top-rated schools in Sugarcreek for 2026 are Miller Avenue Elementary School (8.1/10), Garaway High School (7.6/10), and Legacy Christian School (6.8/10), based on MySchoolScout's analysis of real test data across 8 rated schools. Ratings blend student growth, poverty-adjusted academic achievement, and school environment (plus college readiness for high schools), with equity shown as context, not scored; schools with estimated (proxy) scores are excluded from this ranking.
Schools
16
3 public · 13 private
Avg Score
5.7
out of 10
ZIP Home Values
$304,700
average of medians · ACS
District
1
serving the city
Schools
16
3 public · 13 private
Avg Score
5.7
out of 10
ZIP Home Values
$304,700
average of medians · ACS
District
1
serving the city
Top-Rated Schools in Sugarcreek
Ranked by MySchoolScout composite using only schools with real test data (8 rated schools; 16 schools in the directory). "Value" = points above what student poverty predicts. Estimated (proxy) scores are excluded.
| # | School | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Miller Avenue Elementary School | 8.1 / 10 |
| 2 | Garaway High School | 7.6 / 10 |
| 3 | Legacy Christian School | 6.8 / 10 |
| 4 | Ragersville Elementary School | 5.5 / 10 |
| 5 | Bell Valley School | 4.8 / 10 |
| 6 | Sand Hill School | 4.6 / 10 |
| 7 | Pleasant Valley School | 4.5 / 10 |
| 8 | Walnut Valley | 3.4 / 10 |
See every school — including those with estimated data — in the full directory below. How we rate schools.
Family Snapshot
At a glance- Avg school rating
- 5.7/10
- Avg ZIP median income
- $83,250
- Avg ZIP median home value
- $304,700
- Avg ZIP bachelor's or higher
- 12%
- Avg ZIP commute
- 20 min
- Avg ZIP homeownership
- 80%
25% of schools rated 7+
Household income · Census ACS
Owner-occupied units
Adults 25+
Workers age 16+
Of occupied housing units
Census figures are unweighted averages across ZIP areas containing this city's school listings. ZIP areas may extend beyond city boundaries; these figures describe area residents, not enrolled families.
How Sugarcreek compares
Ohio rank
#369 of 436
cities by avg. school score
Vs. state average
-0.6
below Ohio avg (6.3)
Avg ZIP median income
$83k
117% of Ohio ZIP average
Schools in this city
8
Garaway Local runs Sugarcreek's public schools
3 public schools. Garaway Local is the only district on the page.
Every assigned public school in Sugarcreek is a Garaway Local school (3 of 3).
Among 3 public schools with real test data, composite scores run from 5.5 to 8.1 — the spread is inside Sugarcreek, not a citywide average.
About Schools in Sugarcreek, Ohio
Sugarcreek, Ohio is home to 16 schools, including 3 public schools and 13 private schools. The city's schools span 7 elementary schools, 7 middle schools, and 1 high school.
With an average rating of 5.7 out of 10, schools in Sugarcreek show moderate performance on the MySchoolScout composite scale. The composite blends student growth, poverty-adjusted academic achievement, and school environment — plus college readiness for high schools.
The highest-performing school in Sugarcreek is Miller Avenue Elementary School with a composite score of 8.1/10, demonstrating strong academic outcomes and school quality metrics.
Sugarcreek is served by 1 school district: Garaway Local. These districts collectively serve 1,057 students.
Census context uses ZIP areas containing school listings in Sugarcreek. The average ZIP-area share of adults 25 and older with a bachelor's degree or higher is 12%. The average of ZIP-area median household incomes is $83,250. The average ZIP-area poverty rate is 3.3%.
Browse the schools below to compare ratings, test scores, enrollment, and other key metrics. Use the filters to focus on specific school levels or types that match your family's needs.
Elementary Schools
7 schools| # | School | Rating | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 176 students · Kindergarten–6th | 8.1 | ||
| 2 | 144 students · Kindergarten–6th | 5.5 | ||
Private Schools5 schools Private and public school ratings use different data sources and scoring models. Scores are not directly comparable across school types. | ||||
| 1 | Bell Valley SchoolPrivate 54 students · Kindergarten–8th | Not Rated | ||
| 2 | Walnut ValleyPrivate 71 students · Kindergarten–8th | Not Rated | ||
| 3 | Brush RunPrivate 29 students · Kindergarten–8th | Not Rated | ||
| 4 | Scenic Acres SchoolPrivate 27 students · Kindergarten–8th | Not Rated | ||
| 5 | Troyer ValleyPrivate 23 students · Kindergarten–8th | Not Rated | ||
Middle Schools
7 schools| # | School | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sand Hill SchoolPrivate 48 students · 1st–8th | Not Rated |
| 2 | Pleasant Valley SchoolPrivate 31 students · 1st–8th | Not Rated |
| 3 | Genza BottomPrivate 16 students · 1st–8th | Not Rated |
| 4 | Oak Ridge SchoolPrivate 21 students · 1st–8th | Not Rated |
| 5 | Stony Point SchoolPrivate 20 students · 2nd–8th | Not Rated |
| 6 | Tri-ValleyPrivate 29 students · 1st–8th | Not Rated |
| 7 | Union HillPrivate 11 students · 1st–7th | Not Rated |
High Schools
1 school| # | School | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 436 students · 7th–12th | 7.6 |
Other Schools
1 school| # | School | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Legacy Christian SchoolPrivate 241 students · Kindergarten–12th | Not Rated |
Schools in Sugarcreek
Sugarcreek, Ohio · 16 schools
Community Demographics
Census ACS five-year estimates across 1 ZIP area containing this city's school listings. Source year unverified for this aggregate. Population sums the ZIP estimates; other figures are unweighted ZIP averages. Areas may extend beyond city boundaries and do not describe enrolled families.
Avg ZIP Median Income
$83,250
Avg ZIP Median Home Value
$304,700
Avg ZIP Median Rent
$817/mo
ZIP Population (Sum)
9,071
Avg ZIP Bachelor's or Higher
12%
Avg ZIP Homeownership
80%
Avg ZIP Commute
20 min
Avg ZIP Poverty Rate
3.3%
Community Profile
ZIP areas containing school listings in Sugarcreek average $83,250 across their median household incomes. The average ZIP-area share of adults 25 and older with a bachelor's degree or higher is 12%. The average of ZIP-area median home values is $304,700, with an average of ZIP-area median rents of $817/month. The average ZIP-area poverty rate is 3.3%. The average of ZIP-area commute estimates is 20 minutes. These are unweighted ZIP-area averages. ZIP areas can extend beyond city boundaries and do not describe enrolled families. Source: U.S. Census ACS five-year estimates. Source year unverified for this aggregate.
Schools by Level
- State
- Ohio
- Elementary
- 7
- Middle
- 7
- High
- 1
- Other
- 1
Resources
School District
Other Major Cities in Ohio
Top metros statewide by school count.
How we rate schools
A clear 1–10 score built from public data — growth, academics, and learning environment. No hidden criteria, no pay-to-play.
See how we rateFrequently Asked Questions
Common questions about schools in Sugarcreek, Ohio
How many schools are in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
Sugarcreek has 16 schools, including 3 public and 13 private schools spanning elementary, middle, and high school levels.
What is the average school rating in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The average MySchoolScout composite score for schools in Sugarcreek is 5.7 out of 10, built from student growth, poverty-adjusted academic achievement, and school environment — plus college readiness for high schools.
What is the top-ranked school in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The top-ranked school in Sugarcreek on MySchoolScout is Miller Avenue Elementary School with a composite score of 8.1/10.
What is the best elementary school in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The top-ranked elementary school in Sugarcreek on MySchoolScout is Miller Avenue Elementary School with a composite score of 8.1/10.
What is the best middle school in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The top-ranked middle school in Sugarcreek on MySchoolScout is Sand Hill School with a composite score of 4.6/10.
What is the best high school in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The top-ranked high school in Sugarcreek on MySchoolScout is Garaway High School with a composite score of 7.6/10.
How many school districts serve Sugarcreek, Ohio?
Sugarcreek is served by 1 school district: Garaway Local.
What is the education level in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The average share of adults 25 and older with a bachelor's degree or higher across ZIP areas containing school listings in Sugarcreek is 12%, using Census ACS estimates. This is an unweighted ZIP-area average; these areas may extend beyond city boundaries and do not describe enrolled families.
What income data is available for Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The unweighted average of ZIP-area median household incomes for areas containing school listings in Sugarcreek is approximately $83,250 using Census ACS five-year estimates. The source year for this aggregate has not been verified. ZIP areas may extend beyond city boundaries; this figure describes area residents, not enrolled families.
Are there private schools in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
Yes, Sugarcreek has 13 private schools alongside 3 public schools. The top-rated private school is Legacy Christian School with a score of 6.8/10.
What is the student-teacher ratio in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The average student-teacher ratio across schools in Sugarcreek is 13.2:1. This ratio varies by school, so families should check individual school profiles for specific classroom sizes.
How does MySchoolScout rate schools in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
MySchoolScout rates schools using publicly available data from the NCES Common Core of Data and state education departments. Each school receives a 1-10 composite score built from Student Growth, Poverty-Adjusted Academic Achievement, and School Environment — plus College Readiness for high schools. Weights vary by school level, and equity data is shown for context but not scored.
Related reading
- Best States for Public Schools in 2026: A Complete Rankingdata insights
- Charter Schools vs Public Schools: What the Data Actually Shows (2026)school choice
- The $1,700 Loophole: How the New Federal School Choice Tax Credit Lowers Private Tuition Billsschool choice
- The Funding Paradox: Why the Federal School Choice Tax Credit Might Boost Your Local Public Schoolschool choice
- The New School Choice Map: Is Your State Participating in the Federal Tuition Tax Credit?data insights
Get school insights in your inbox
New rankings and parent guides, free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.
Data from NCES Common Core of Data, Ohio Dept. of Education, and U.S. Census ACS for the 2023–24 school year.Rankings computed by MySchoolScout. See all data sources.