Nevin Avenue Elementary vs Third Street Elementary

Third Street Elementary ranks #8 of 9,533 California schools, placing it among the top fraction of a percent statewide. Nevin Avenue Elementary ranks #446 of 9,533 — still a strong position, clearing roughly 95% of California elementaries — but the 438-place gap reflects a meaningful difference in overall performance. Third Street Elementary's overall rating of 9.6/10 sits 0.9 points above Nevin Avenue Elementary's 8.7/10, a gap that compounds across multiple scoring dimensions.

The academic score delta is the sharpest dividing line between these two schools. Third Street Elementary earns a perfect 10.0/10 in academics against Nevin Avenue Elementary's 7.8/10 — a 2.2-point difference that signals substantially higher tested proficiency levels. Growth scores are far closer: Nevin Avenue Elementary posts a 9.2/10 while Third Street Elementary reaches 9.9/10, a 0.7-point gap. That tight growth margin suggests Nevin Avenue Elementary teachers are moving students forward at a competitive pace regardless of where they start, even as Third Street Elementary's absolute academic ceiling remains higher.

The demographic profiles of these two schools diverge sharply. Nevin Avenue Elementary enrolls 492 students with 97% qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a predominantly low-income population. Third Street Elementary serves 691 students with 43% on free or reduced lunch — a more economically mixed community. Nevin Avenue Elementary offers a lower student-teacher ratio of 20.5:1 compared to Third Street Elementary's 22.3:1, meaning each teacher at Nevin Avenue Elementary manages roughly two fewer students on average, which can translate to more individualized attention in the classroom. Both schools serve grades KG through 05 and sit 6.5 miles apart in Los Angeles.

Both schools operate at the same grade span, KG–05, so families are not choosing between different level structures. The choice turns on what a family weights more: Third Street Elementary's commanding state rank and top-tier academic score, or Nevin Avenue Elementary's tighter class sizes and its strong growth score of 9.2/10 — evidence that the school consistently advances students relative to their starting points.