Skip to main content

Excellent

#362 of 2,463 schools in NJ

Top 15% in state

Old Mill Elementary School

Elementary School · Wall Township Public School District

2119 OLD MILL ROAD OLD MILL ROAD, Sea Girt, NJ 08750

Enrollment

384

Student-Teacher

9.6:1

Score

8.0

Grades

Kindergarten – 5th

Updated 2022-23

How this school compares

New Jersey elementary schools

#242 of 1,496

In district

#5 of 7

Wall Township Public School District

School environment

9.0 / 10

Exceptional

About Old Mill Elementary School

Old Mill Elementary School serves 384 students in kindergarten through fifth grade in Sea Girt, New Jersey, earning recognition as one of the state's stronger elementary schools. With a MySchoolScout rating of 7.6 out of 10 and ranking #292 out of 2,475 New Jersey elementary schools, the school places in the 88th percentile statewide. The school maintains an excellent student-teacher ratio of 9.6 to 1 with 40 full-time equivalent teachers, allowing for more individualized attention in the classroom.

Academically, Old Mill Elementary demonstrates solid performance with 62% of students achieving proficiency or above in English Language Arts and 67% reaching proficiency in mathematics across all grade levels. Located in Monmouth County's 08750 zip code area, the school serves a well-educated community where 71% of residents hold bachelor's degrees or higher. The neighborhood reflects affluence with a median household income of $154,130 and median home values around $1,009,800, while maintaining a very low poverty rate of just 1.3%.

Old Mill Elementary operates as a regular public school in Sea Girt's large suburban setting, providing elementary education within a prosperous coastal community known for its strong commitment to academic excellence.

What Parents Should Know

With a student-teacher ratio of 9.6:1, Old Mill Elementary School offers a notably low ratio compared to the national average. This typically means smaller class sizes and more opportunities for one-on-one interaction between students and teachers.

Score Breakdown

Full Profile · 3/3 metrics
Student Progress7.4Very Good50%
Year-over-year improvement in student test scores.
View breakdown
Years of Data4
Annual Change-0.38 pts/yr
Data Period2019–2024
TrendStable
Academics8.3Excellent30%
Student proficiency on state tests, adjusted for community poverty levels.
View breakdown
Math Proficiency67%
Reading/ELA Proficiency62%
Math vs. State Avg+19.1 pts
Reading vs. State Avg+18.1 pts
Overall Proficiency65%
Expected (poverty-adj.)60%
vs. Expected+4.0 pts
Adjusted Percentile74th
College ReadinessNot Available

Data not available for this school

Resources & Environment9.0Exceptional20%
Student-teacher ratio, per-pupil spending, and attendance.
View breakdown
Student-Teacher Ratio9.6:1
Per-Pupil Spending$28,224

Old Mill Elementary School — Students at Old Mill Elementary School score 64% proficient, which is above what's typical for similar communities (expected: 60%).

How we calculate scores →

Equity & Diversity

Shown separately, not included in overall score

Free/Reduced Lunch

7%

Students qualifying for federal meal assistance

Test Scores NJ NJSLA (2023-24)

Math Proficiency 62.1%
School
State
44.6%
ELA Proficiency 66.5%
School
State
49.3%

Based on 13 test records from NJ state assessments. About our data

Proficiency Trend

→ Stable

Average proficiency (% at or above grade level) across Math & ELA over time.

2019
Math
71%
ELA
70%
2021*
Math
37%
ELA
62%
2022
Math
67%
ELA
62%
2024
Math
65.9%
ELA
68.3%

* COVID-affected year — test participation was uneven nationwide. This data is weighted at 50% in the Growth score calculation.

Source: EdFacts (NCES) and state assessment data. Growth score: 7.4/10.

How Old Mill Elementary School Compares

See how Old Mill Elementary School performs across key quality dimensions compared to state benchmarks.

Overall Score
8.0/10
85th percentile in NJ
Academic
8.3/10
8.3/10
Growth
7.4/10
Above average
Environment
9.0/10
Above average

Funding & Resources

Free/Reduced Lunch
Students eligible for subsidized meals
7%
Teaching Staff
10:1 student-teacher ratio
40 teachers

Location

2119 OLD MILL ROAD OLD MILL ROAD, Sea Girt, NJ 08750

Nearby Alternatives

Families considering Old Mill Elementary School may also want to explore other elementary schools in the area. H W Mountz Elementary School (rated 9.7/10, 1.7 miles away, in nearby Spring Lake), which scores notably higher. Another option is Sea Girt Elementary School (rated 9.6/10, 0.9 miles away), which scores notably higher. Additionally, G. Harold Antrim Elementary School (rated 9.3/10, 3.2 miles away, in nearby Point Pleasant Beach), which scores notably higher. For more schools in Sea Girt, see our Sea Girt schools guide .

Nearby Schools

20 within 3.2 mi
School Distance Rating
THE BROOKSIDE SCHOOL Sea Girt 0.4 mi 5.2
Manasquan High School Manasquan 1.0 mi 7.6
Sea Girt Elementary School Sea Girt 0.9 mi 9.6
Manasquan Elementary School Manasquan 1.1 mi 7.9
HILL AND DALE SCHOOL Manasquan 1.1 mi
Wall Intermediate School Wall 1.2 mi 8.4
ATLANTIS PREP SCHOOL Manasquan 1.1 mi
Spring Lake Heights Elementary School Spring Lake Heights 1.3 mi 6.9
ST CATHARINE SCHOOL Spring Lake 1.3 mi 5.7
Wall High School Wall 1.9 mi 6.8
Communications High School Wall 2.0 mi 7.5
H W Mountz Elementary School Spring Lake 1.7 mi 9.7
MONMOUTH MONTESORI ACADEMY Spring Lake 1.8 mi 4.4
Brielle Elementary School Brielle 2.1 mi 6.7
Wall Primary School Wall 2.4 mi 5.4
West Belmar Elementary School Wall 2.3 mi 8.8
Academy Charter High School Lake Como 2.5 mi 6.2
Belmar Elementary Belmar 2.9 mi 8.5
SEA LAVENDAR MONTESSORI Belmar 2.9 mi
G. Harold Antrim Elementary School Point Pleasant Beach 3.2 mi 9.3

Neighborhood Census ACS (2019-2023)

Census data for ZIP 08750 (ACS 2019-2023 5-Year Estimates) · Data sources

Median Income

$150,357

Median Home Value

$1,117,800

Median Rent

$2,039/mo

Population

3,624

College Educated

71%

Homeownership

83.5%

Avg Commute

26.4 min

Poverty Rate

2.7%

Median Age

57

Community Profile

The community surrounding Old Mill Elementary School has a median household income of $150,357. It is a well-educated community where 71% of adults hold a bachelor's degree or higher. The median home value in the area is $1,117,800, with a median rent of $2,039/month. The local poverty rate of 2.7% is relatively low. The average commute for residents is 26 minutes. Source: U.S. Census ACS 2022 5-Year Estimates.

Similar Schools

Schools in the same state with comparable level, size, and ratings

School Rating
AL-HIKMAH ELEMENTARY SCHOOL Prospect Park, NJ 8.0
Allenwood Elementary School Wall, NJ 8.0
Betsy Ross Elementary Mahwah, NJ 8.0
Delaware Township School Sergeantsville, NJ 8.0
Edith A. Bogert Elementary School Upper Saddle River, NJ 8.0
Glenwood School Short Hills, NJ 8.0

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Old Mill Elementary School

What grades does Old Mill Elementary School serve?

Old Mill Elementary School serves students in grades Kindergarten through 5th.

How many students attend Old Mill Elementary School?

Old Mill Elementary School has an enrollment of approximately 384 students.

What is the student-teacher ratio at Old Mill Elementary School?

The student-teacher ratio at Old Mill Elementary School is 9.6:1. A lower ratio generally means more individual attention per student. The national average is approximately 16:1 for public schools.

How does Old Mill Elementary School rank in NJ?

Old Mill Elementary School is ranked #362 out of 2,463 schools in NJ.

What is Old Mill Elementary School's MySchoolScout rating?

Old Mill Elementary School has a composite rating of 8.0 out of 10 on MySchoolScout. This score combines academic performance, student growth, and school environment into a single score. Equity data is shown separately for context.

What are the test scores at Old Mill Elementary School?

Based on the most recent state assessment data, Old Mill Elementary School has 62.1% math proficiency and 66.5% reading/ELA proficiency.

Is Old Mill Elementary School a charter school?

No, Old Mill Elementary School is not a charter school. It is a traditional public school operated by the local school district.

Is Old Mill Elementary School a Title I school?

No, Old Mill Elementary School is not currently a Title I school.

What does the Free & Reduced Lunch percentage mean for Old Mill Elementary School?

7.0% of students at Old Mill Elementary School qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. This is a commonly used indicator of economic need and provides important context when interpreting test scores.

11 schools nearby View map →

Neighborhood Context

Walk Score
46 Car-Dependent
Bike Score
47 Somewhat Bikeable
City Safety
Average (655/100K)

Powered by Walk Score

FBI UCR 2024. City-level (Sea Girt). Data >1 year old.

Quick Facts NCES CCD (SY 2022-23)

Grades
Kindergarten – 5th
Enrollment
384
Student-Teacher Ratio
9.6:1
Teachers (FTE)
40
Free/Reduced Lunch
7.0%
Type
regular
Setting
Large Suburb
County
Monmouth County
Data Year
2023–2024

District

Wall Township Public School District
District Enrollment
3,186
Schools in District
7
Per-Pupil Spending
$29,653
District Rank
#5 of 7

How We Rate Schools

Every school receives a composite score from 1 to 10 based on four pillars: Academic Performance (50%), Student Growth (20%), Equity (15%), and Learning Environment (15%). Scores are built from publicly available data including standardized test results, enrollment figures, and school climate indicators.

Read our full methodology

Related reading

Get school insights in your inbox

New rankings, best-schools lists, and parent guides — delivered free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.