Best Schools in Chesterton, Indiana

Chesterton's public school system covers 8 ranked schools, and the numbers lean strongly in parents' favor. The city posts an average score of 8.2 out of 10 — and 7 of those 8 schools, or 88%, clear a 7.0 or better. That kind of floor-level consistency is notable. Most cities this size show a wider gap between their top and bottom performers; Chesterton compresses that range toward the high end.

The ceiling is set by Westchester Intermediate School, which scores 9.4 out of 10 — the city's top-ranked school. Close behind are Brummitt Elementary at 9.2 and Liberty Elementary at 9.0, two of the strongest elementary options in the area. Chesterton Middle School (8.9) and Liberty Intermediate School (8.8) round out the top five. Every middle-level school in the city lands at 8.8 or above, meaning the transition from elementary to middle school doesn't come with a performance cliff.

What stands out is the depth of quality, not just the ceiling. With only one school sitting below that 88% high-performer cluster, parents have real flexibility regardless of which school their child is assigned to. Elementary-age families can count on at least two consistently strong options in Brummitt and Liberty. Families with middle schoolers face the same favorable picture: three schools all scoring 8.8 or higher, led by Westchester Intermediate at 9.4.

For parents comparing Chesterton to other Indiana cities, the 8.2 citywide average and 88% above-7.0 rate are the numbers worth anchoring to. The performance floor is unusually high, and the top end — Westchester at 9.4 — shows the ceiling is competitive too. Families choosing between suburban Indiana districts will find Chesterton holds up well under direct comparison. The practical takeaway: school assignment carries lower stakes here than in most markets, because even the one outlier school in this city still clears a respectable bar.