New York City Geographic District #31 School District

New York City Geographic District 31 serves 60,047 students across Staten Island, making it one of the borough's primary public school systems. With 74 ranked schools, the district offers families a wide range of options at every grade level, from elementary through middle school. That breadth matters when comparing districts — more schools means more variation, and knowing where each campus sits relative to peers gives parents a sharper picture than averages alone.

The district's average school rating of 7.2 out of 10 positions it as a solid performer, and several campuses push well above that baseline. Naples Street Elementary School leads the district with a 9.4 rating, placing it among the strongest elementary programs in the borough. IS 51 Edwin Markham and PS 6 Corporal Allan F. Kivlehan School each earn an 8.8, giving middle and elementary families high-performing options beyond the top-ranked school. PS 26 Carteret School and PS 39 Francis J. Murphy Jr. both rate 8.6, rounding out a cluster of five schools that consistently outpace the district average by more than a full point.

That concentration of high-rated schools matters in practical terms. A district averaging 7.2 across 74 campuses can mask significant school-to-school differences, but District 31's top tier is dense enough that families in many neighborhoods have a strong option within reach. Parents comparing districts should weigh both the average and the spread — District 31 delivers on both counts at the upper end.

For families actively evaluating schools, the rating gap between the district's top performers and its average underscores the value of school-level research. Naples Street Elementary's 9.4 sits more than two points above the district mean, a meaningful margin in any peer comparison. Prioritizing visits and enrollment timelines for the 8.6-to-9.4 range — five schools across elementary and middle grades — gives parents a focused shortlist without requiring them to sort through all 74 options from scratch.